Squats Vs Deadlifts

+ Font Size -


Which is Better for Strength, Mass, and Power: Squats or Deadlifts?

Squats and deadlifts are two of the most common exercises in any Strength Coach's repertoire. They're popular lifts because they work a number of big muscles and can help you gain strength and power in ways that few other exercises can.

But which one is superior for gaining muscle mass, strength, and power?

The answer, as is typical with such issues, is that it relies on a number of things, including the sport you play, your body type, your aim, and many others.

Which is better for strength, mass, and power: squats or deadlifts?

Squats and deadlifts are two of the most commonly used moves in a Strength Coach's arsenal. They're popular because they work a lot of huge muscle groups and can help you gain strength and power in ways that few other exercises can.

Which one, though, is superior for increasing strength, mass, and power?

As is typical with such issues, the answer is that it depends on a number of things, including the sport you play, your body type, your aim, and many more.

When it comes to power, it's quite straightforward. It's the ability to quickly generate force. The more force we can generate, the more power we can generate. The bigger the power, the faster we can produce that force. The ultimate goal of sports performance is to be able to generate the greatest amount of force in the shortest amount of time. Speed is an advantage in practically every sport, and power equals speed.

Most strength coaches would design a program to increase all three of these criteria, but we need additional information to choose between squats and deadlifts to improve all three.

EMG investigations can be used to determine whether particular muscles fire more during the squat than the deadlift. Unfortunately, EMG numbers do not always imply motor unit recruitment, as they measure electrical activity rather than real muscle activity. So, it's an estimate that should theoretically be similar to muscle activation, but because it's not a direct measurement of muscular contraction, it can't be used to infer strength or hypertrophy gains.

With that said, an imperfect measure is preferable to no measure, and numerous research have been conducted to compare the muscle activation differences between squats and deadlifts. The differences between squats and deadlift kinetics – essentially how much force was delivered by the knee and hip joints during each exercise – were investigated in a study In 2018, the Journal of Strength and Conditioning published an article on the subject.

What they discovered is unsurprising: back squats put more force on the knee joint, which works the quadriceps more, but the deadlift puts more strain on the hip joint, which works the glutes and hamstrings more. Squats target the quadriceps, whereas deadlifts target the glutes and hamstrings.

Similar findings have been reported in a number of other investigations. Squats, for example, target more than just the quads (hamstrings, glutes, adductors, core, and other muscles, to mention a few), while deadlifts target more than just the glutes and hamstrings (calves, back extensors, lats, shoulders, grip, and others). If we're searching for differences between the movements, we can simply say that we emphasize deadlifts if we want to train the hips more. We prioritize squats if we want to work our quads more.

Returning to our previous discussion of the force vector — In 2018, a study published in the Plos One[BMA1] Journal evaluated the effects of vertically and horizontally oriented power exercises on sprint performance and vertical jump height. Vertically directed workouts, such as back squats, enhanced vertical leaping ability more than horizontally directed exercises, according to the researchers. Hip thrusts were employed instead of deadlifts in this investigation. Other research has found that the deadlift and hip thrust, which both predominantly target the glutes, can deliver similar strength and performance gains.

Strength's Practical Implications

One of the most crucial elements to consider when deciding which exercise will build the most strength is HOW you will assess that strength.

In the instance of our volleyball player, it's more practical to test them in a manner that mimics their sport, therefore the squat would most likely be used. If you're utilizing a 1RM squat as a test, focusing the squat in training is clearly the best option.

Horizontal force, on the other hand, is more crucial for our sprinter. So, we could put them to the test with a 1RM deadlift or a hip thrust (choosing the deadlift is obviously the best). If it's something different, you'll need to figure out which exercise is the most relevant to the test.

Another item to consider is the athlete's LESS proficient skill. So, if you have a volleyball player with huge, powerful glutes and hamstrings but relatively weak quads, it makes a lot of sense to use the squat to develop their total strength profile rather than targeting glutes. When strength levels are about equal, however, the exercise that is most specific to the "test" will nearly always give higher results.

Unfortunately, there isn't a clear answer as to whether squats or deadlifts are superior for building strength. It is determined by a variety of circumstances. What is the most appropriate response? Do both exercises to ensure that you're strengthening as many muscles as possible and to detect any areas of weakness. Male athletes are considered advanced when they can squat 2x their bodyweight and deadlift 2.5x their bodyweight, according to most strength experts. When female athletes can squat 1.5 times their bodyweight and deadlift 2 times their bodyweight, they are called advanced. If players can handle these figures, it's probably best to focus on the workout that is most relevant to their sport.

We do know, however, that improving lower-body strength will almost certainly increase sprinting abilities. Squat strength ES and sprint ES had a "very strong significant connection (r = -0.77; p = 0.0001)," according to a comprehensive review and meta-analysis published in 2014.

So, if you want to improve your speed in any sport, you must first improve your strength. Remember how we described power: the ability to generate a large amount of force fast. The first part of that is strength. As a result, if we can improve strength, we can improve power (and therefore speed).

Implications for the Masses

It depends on your goal, as we've explained. If you want to bulk up your quads, the squat should be your first priority. If you desire bigger glutes, the deadlift or hip thrust are more likely to help. You are erroneous if you believe that a single activity will make everything bigger.

We won't spend a lot of time talking about gaining bulk because most athletes aren't only interested with having huge legs. Despite the fact that studies have found a link between muscle cross-sectional area and force-production capabilities (i.e. strength), it's a bit of a chicken-and-egg situation. Is it true that big legs mean powerful legs? Or do powerful legs have an inherent tendency to be larger? Should hypertrophy take precedence over strength?

The answer is complex, but the truth is that we should probably strive for both. We should spend time concentrating on muscular hypertrophy because size DOES contribute to strength. However, in order to acquire maximum strength, we must also spend time at the higher end of our loading range. We have to lift big things in order to get better at lifting heavy things, right? This is why, in most periodization models, athletes go through a hypertrophy phase before moving on to a strength phase, which is followed by a power phase. To enhance power output, we must first develop a foundation for size, then increase muscle strength.

It's also why, in most studies of maximum strength and power characteristics, persons with a lot of training experience are preferred. Overall leg size is achieved through performing a variety of exercises, including squats, deadlifts, hip thrusts, and single leg work, as well as a variety of loading regimens. That's why strength and conditioning coaching is referred to as "the art and science."

And what about power?

You've probably figured out which workout is superior for increasing power production by now, right? It depends, as you may have imagined. As we've discussed before, you must concentrate on what is unique to the athlete and their sport, but this is especially true when training for power.

Most power phases occur near the conclusion of a training cycle, when an athlete is meant to be "peaking," thus it's still important to train the movement patterns and contraction velocities that will most closely mimic their activity.

You're probably sick of hearing "it depends" by now. And you undoubtedly understand that while training athletes, we should use both squats and deadlifts, but we should prioritize the exercise that is most specific to their sport.

What should coaches think about when putting together their programs?

Single-leg alternatives — most sports require speed, power, and agility from only one leg, rather than both legs at once. We should practice a wide range of single-leg variations, including:

Pistol squat, step-ups, Bulgarian split squats, box squats, leg press, and quad extension are all variations of the one-leg squat.

Variations of the 1-leg deadlift include the 1-leg RDL, 1-leg hip thrust, and machine kick-backs.

Coaching a group of 20 or more athletes on appropriate technique at the same time can be difficult, and resources at some sites are limited. So, here are some simpler alternatives to consider when working with large groups, newcomers, or in settings with limited equipment:

Goblet Squats - Anteriorly loaded squats can often correct "bad form" without the need for any coaching. With the goal of getting the thighs parallel to the floor or deeper, you can limit the depth to only what the athlete can handle.

Bodyweight Bulgarian Split Squats/Rear Foot Elevated Lunges– A easy technique to get started with single leg exercises, especially if you don't have much equipment. It's also a good idea to do this early on in a program to help with balance, coordination, and foot strength.

D-bell Single Leg RDL - Loading the hip hinge pattern in this way stresses not only sagittal plane stability, but also transverse plane stability. A hand-supported variant may be preferable for athletes with stability or motor control difficulties.

Weighted Sit-to-Stand or Pin Squats — These variations can be utilized to load partial ranges of motion as athletes focus on full-depth squat control. To overload the muscles, it can also be utilized for max strength/heavy half squats.

Sumo Squats — Squatting to parallel can be a nightmare for athletes with longer femurs than torsos (you know, all legs, no torso). Starting with the hips externally rotated functionally shortens the femurs and allows for improved depth and form. This modification may also boost glute activation as a bonus.

Barbell Rack Pulls/Block Pulls — The pin-squat deadlift can be used in a similar fashion. Add eccentric and/or isometric activity to a partial range of motion that the athlete can control to assist extend the range of motion the athlete can control. In max strength stages, it can also be employed for supra-maximal loading.

Squats and Deadlifts with the Trap Bar/Hex Bar — The trap bar is one of my favorite tools for both of these exercises. It enables athletes to retain the load closer to their hips and reduces the spine's sheering pressures. Although this version sacrifices maximal glute tension, the improved form and enhanced lat activation, as well as the neutral shoulder position (rather than internal rotation with a barbell), making it a good option.

Barbell Hip Thrusts - These are a great complement to the deadlift and should be done together to get the most strength across the range of motion. They can also be done using a smith rack, a landmine, or bands.

Deadlifts with kettlebells and variants – Kettlebells are useful for teaching the hinge pattern and eventually advancing to kettlebell swings for power and explosiveness when you don't have enough barbells or are merely trying to teach the exercises.

Last Word

Use all of your tools while exercising for optimum strength, including band-assisted variants such at the bottom of a deep squat and accommodating resistance with items like chains (to maximize strength in lockout positions). Although the benefit isn't evident, and this is usually best left for advanced athletes, if you have individuals that require more strength stimulus, this is a good alternative.

Aim for higher volume loads (sets x reps x weight on bar) while training for mass, and use workout variants that allow you to keep your technique. Heavy half squats and block pull deadlifts come in handy at this point. Blood flow restriction training for accessory movements like isolated quad and hamstring work can also aid enhance hypertrophy if you have the capabilities.

write a comment